Both were involved in the network of. You may send this item to up to five recipients. Not knowing this, a year-old from Bremen had his hand blown off in Malville while attempting to dispose of a tear gas grenade Revue belge de philologie et d’histoire , tome 89, fasc. There’s a problem loading this menu right now. The unfamiliarity of foreigners with the context in which they were protesting also put them at a disadvantage during the demonstration, with German protesters misreading the situation in Malville in a number of ways. For example, the Maoist-inspired.
Your request to send this item has been completed. Create lists, bibliographies and reviews: The local committees that were supposed to form the backbone of the movement were relatively weak; unlike at other protest sites in France and West Germany, the mobilisation in Malville only really took off once the power company had already taken care of land purchases, administrative procedures, and other potential points of blockage, so many locals were resigned about the project. The protest at Creys-Malville in July was part of a transnational movement against nuclear power that had begun to develop in the early s, with support networks that criss-crossed ideological and geographical boundaries. The unfamiliarity of foreigners with the context in which they were protesting also put them at a disadvantage during the demonstration, with German protesters misreading the situation in Malville in a number of ways. These dramatic events did not escape the attention of French media, especially not the activist press, which portrayed them either as evidence of the brutality and repression that nuclear power entailed, or as an example of the new strategy for protesters to follow: Door dit protest in een transnationaal en chronologisch overzicht te plaatsen van Frans en West-Duits verzet tegen kernenergie, toont dit artikel hoe gebeurtenissen in West-Duitsland een belangrijke invloed hadden op die in Frankrijk, maar ook hoe transnationaliteit interageerde met fundamentelere problemen van locale mobilisatie.
Even these could backfire badly in the French setting though.
Transnationality as a Liability? The Anti-Nuclear Movement at Malville – Persée
For many French anti-nuclear protesters, West Germany had come to represent their hopes, their fears, or some combination of the two. Advanced Search Find a Library. Over time, a certain model evolved from the collective experiences activists accumulated in local struggles within these networks. Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands.
Brokdorf not only made apparent the changed conditions of protest in West Germany, it also concretely changed them in France, as the French state and nuclear industry drew their own conclusions from developments across the Rhine. I will then discuss how developments in West Germany in late led to a rapid change in the conditions of protest in France in Though each of these protests depended on specific local conditions, together they seemed to constitute a coherent image of the possibilities for local protests of international importance, wherever they might occur.
The central hub of many protest networks malviole.
Add a review and share your thoughts with other readers. For social movement actors and for social scientists alike, it can be very difficult to predict beforehand the success or failure of a particular protest event.
Emissaries from the Larzac and protesters with experience there carried these lessons with them to other protests, including the one in Wyhl 5. The protest in Malville was the last mass anti-nuclear demonstration in France for several years, and those that eventually followed it either took the form of festivals La Hague, or separated militant confrontations.
Violence may have come from all sides during the protest, but the force exercised by the authorities was overwhelming, lethal and indiscriminate. The failure of the protest in Malville demonstrates how, in the absence of good coordination and strong local support, international solidarity and transnational protest participation can be turned from an advantage into a liability for a social movement.
In Alsace and Baden, activists from both sides of the Rhine fought together against a nuclear power plant in Fessenheim France, starting ina lead processing plant in Marckolsheim France, and planned nuclear power crwys in Breisach and Wyhl West Germany, and Brokdorf thus cast a shadow over Malville, leading.
Please enter your name.
These dramatic events did not escape the attention of French media, especially not the activist press, which portrayed them either as evidence of the brutality and repression that nuclear power entailed, or as an example of the new strategy for protesters to follow: Protest there attracted international attention when the locals hosted spectacular rallies in, and that drew crowds of 50, people.
The mslville requirements or preferences of your reviewing publisher, classroom teacher, institution or organization should be applied.
Aside from the unprepared Molotov cocktails cited malvills, there were some other offensive weapons 17 clubs, 5 slingshots and one tear gas grenade. These local mobilisations were closely interrelated: Please enter the message.
Reviews User-contributed reviews Add a review and share your thoughts with other readers.
Tompkins however unequal, and reinforced linkages between protest in France and West Germany. East Dane Designer Men’s Fashion.
Learn more about Amazon Prime. Amazon Advertising Find, attract, and engage customers. Some of those interviewed for this project described the protest at Malville as a trauma that provoked feelings of powerlessness; one interviewee who went to Malville refused even to talk about it, immediately changing the subject to focus instead on the more creative, small-scale protests that took place thereafter.
For example, by working in cross-border networks, activists may be able to circumvent limitations in their own country, apply pressure from abroad against local opponents and select the best terrain for fighting for their cause from among various national and international venues.
In both France and West Germany, the battle cries calling for large-scale site occupations, so prevalent in the preceding years, were dropped almost overnight, at least for a time. The unfamiliarity of foreigners with the context in which they were protesting also put them at a disadvantage during the demonstration, with German protesters misreading the situation in Malville in a number of ways.